Find it at your library!

A gender-bent mystery in which the famous, brilliant detective is not Sherlock, but Charlotte, Holmes is not something I knew I wanted, but now that I’ve read it, I want ALL THE SEQUELS. I need more Charlotte and her delightful Mrs. Watson!

In this first entry in the series, Charlotte has just irreparably ruined her own reputation—on purpose. Determined to make a go of life on her own instead of depending on a man, she is looking for a way to earn a living when three people turn up dead, all from the same poison. Charlotte thinks the deaths must be linked, but it won’t be easy for a woman in her position to investigate.  

If you like your mysteries on the cerebral and genteel side, this is the series you want. Thomas’s writing is just so classy. I tried to come up with a better way to put it, but that’s the word that fits the best. It’s like pretty pastel petit fours lined up in the window of a French bake shop: precise and attractive and sweet. Classy. It’s even more amazing when you consider that English isn’t her first language.

That said, it doesn’t make for an easy, breezy read. I actually finished the book and then immediately reread the last third to make sure I had everything right. This is not the kind of book you can snooze through and expect a big payoff. There are a lot of minor characters to keep track of, and they all seem to have complicated relationships with each other. Plot-wise, this book is a tangled web. But I liked Charlotte and her friends so much I was willing to do a bit of unraveling to get my money’s worth. As you would expect from a character based on Sherlock Holmes, Charlotte is pretty complex, and it’s obvious that what we learn about her in this volume is just the tip of the iceberg. I can’t wait to get my hands on book two!

Find it at your library!

My husband Adam is the king of long audio books. He’s listened to some doorstoppers in his time, loading up the 6-CD changer in his car and listening on his daily commute. In that fashion, he’s read Doris Kearns Goodwin’s thousand-page Team of Rivals about Lincoln’s rise to the presidency, an apparently quite thorough biography of Albert Einstein, and at least a couple of Bill Bryson’s travelogues. I always knew what he was listening to, as he’d pepper our conversations with tidbits gleaned from his audio adventures.

So when I decided recently to add audio books to my reading repertoire, I remembered Adam’s success with long books and figured I could do that too. The Shadow of the Wind seemed like a safe choice: it’s about book lovers, and it came highly recommended by several of my friends. So what if it was almost 500 pages? How many hours is that, anyway?

The answer: A LOT OF HOURS.

My listening experience started off so well. The reader, Jonathan Davis, is stellar. Because the book is set in Barcelona, it demands a reader who can flit back and forth between English and gorgeously accented Spanish at will, and Davis does so with aplomb. I have to admit to swooning a bit at his first rolled “r.” I’m tempted to seek out other audio books he’s narrated just because he’s such a talented voice actor…but that may not be the best idea, and here’s why:

If a story doesn’t have momentum to burn, I can’t stick with it in audio. No matter how skilled the reader, no matter how fascinating the characters, if there isn’t a strong sense of forward movement, I will stall out. And this book bogged down HARD for me in the last quarter.

The beginning had me gripped: Daniel Sempere is given a rare book as a child. He becomes fascinated with its mysterious author, Julian Carax, when he discovers that someone has been going around collecting all the copies of Carax’s novels and burning them. Why would someone want to do this? Who was Carax anyway, and where is he now? Daniel’s efforts to find out lead him on many a death-defying adventure.

Unfortunately, the revelations are so slow in coming they flirt with tedium. And it seems an ill-advised choice that the bulk of the long-sought answers come by way of a passive info-dump instead of sprouting up naturally in the course of active scenes. For about the last three hours or so, I was so ready for the book to be done (and for the overemotional handwringing to end) I almost didn’t care what happened anymore. Maybe this is one that would have worked better on the page—though it’s hard to imagine that, knowing I would have missed out on Davis’s skilled evocation of the streets of Barcelona.